چکیده:
در منابع گوناگون همواره خواندهایم که سوسیالیسم و مارکسیسم در صدر مشروطه و با پیدایش سازمانها و گروههای سوسیالدموکرات نفوذ خود را به ایران آغاز کرد. دو پرسش مهم در این زمینه مطرح میشود: 1. مردم مسلمان ایران چگونه و در چه شرایطی متأثر از این اندیشههای غربی شدند؟ 2. در این مقطع زمانی که نفوذ مارکسیسم به ایران آغاز شده است، این اندیشه در چه سطحی و از چه راهی گسترش پیدا میکند؟ در این پژوهش، تلاش خواهیم کرد با گردآوری دادههای موجود در اسناد تاریخی و بهرهبرداری از روش تحلیل کیفی اسنادی، به این پرسشها پاسخ دهیم. استدلال ما این است که در گام نخست ایرانیها بیش از آنکه به مبانی نظری مارکسیسم توجه کنند، اثرگرفته از شعارهای ایدئولوژیک این اندیشه شدند و نخستین بار پیش از پرداختن به نظریه، به برخی مبانی سوسیالیستی آن هم در قالب اهداف سازمانی توجه کردند. البته در این مقطع تلاشهایی هم در جهت ترویج نظری سوسیالیسم و مارکسیسم انجام گرفت، ولی سطح معرفی این اندیشه از مبانی آغازین و معرفی کلیات فرا نمیرفت. با همه اینها، این خود پایههای نخستین طرح یک اندیشه و بهوجود آمدن جریانی نو پیرامون آن در ایران بود و در این فرایند پیشزمینههای آغازین گسترش سوسیالیسم و مارکسیسم در ایران فراهم شد.
In various sources, we have been reading that socialism and Marxism began their influence in Iran after the adoption of the Constitution along with the emergence of social democratic organizations and groups. In this study, we intend to address the following questions about Iran and Marxism: 1. When did the influence of Marxism begin in Iran? 2. What were the characteristics of the initial discourse of the Left in Iran? 3. How, under what circumstances, and at what level Marxism influenced the Moslem Iranians? The familiarity of Iranians with socialist thought occurred shortly before the culmination of Iran’s Constitutional Revolution in 1911. The introduction of socialist and Marxist thought to Iran, as a result of Iranians' encounter with Western intellectual and cultural system, provided the ideological basis for the formation of one of the nascent trends in Iran's political arena. Iranians' attention to socialism and Marxism at the beginning and on a general level was influenced by the political and inspirational slogans of Marxist intellectuals and activists, particularly those in Transcaucasia, rather than the ideological or philosophical aspects of these new ideals. These slogans were attractive to Iranian politicians and activists in that region because they were interested in helping the lower strata of society, specifically the workers. Considering the poor living conditions of this class combined with their growing size of population at that time, Marxism and socialism seemed to provide a new theoretical basis for solving the problems of the working class. Therefore, at the beginning of the spread of Marxism and socialism in Iran, their tenets and slogans were used in some political parties and groups’ manifestos and programs. An example of these parties is Ferqeh-ye Ejtemaʿiyun-e ʿʿamiyun (Social Democratic Party) which is considered to be the first Iranian socialist organization established by Iranian emigrants in Transcaucasia. Using the documentary research method, we systematically analyzed historical official documents as our main data sources. We argue that initially Iranians were influenced by the ideological slogans of Marxism rather than its theoretical foundations. At the beginning, they were attracted to this ideology’s socialist foundations in the form of organizational goals for their political parties and groups before addressing its theoretical details. Of course, efforts were made to promote socialism and Marxism, but the level of their introduction to Iranians did not go beyond the basic principles and generalities. It is evident that Marxism and its call for a classless society did not have a great influence on the Iranian peoples' political view of society. However, Marx's social theories and Marxism’s commitment to political struggle to improve material conditions of the underprivileged social groups provided an intellectual basis of the research conducted by a number of contemporary Iranian scholars and influenced their political thought.
خلاصه ماشینی:
٢ اين دست از منابع بيش از آنکه به ريشه هاي نظري پيدايش سوسياليسم و مارکسيسم در ايران توجه داشته باشند، بيشتر ابعاد تنها تاريخي پيدايش گروه ها و سازمان هاي ذيل عنوان سوسيال دموکراسي را بررسي قرار ميکنند.
براي نمونه ميتوان از نظريه پردازي بوررامنسکي در مقاله اي با عنوان «انقلاب ايرانيان » در اين زمينه ، و يا ديدگاه هاي ايوانف در کتاب انقلاب مشروطيت ايران که البته به زبان فارسي نيز ترجمه شده است ، اشاره کرد.
نتيجه عملي اين همسويي ايجاد نخستين حزب سياسي ايران با عنوان اجتماعيون عاميون در منطقه قفقاز بود که اهداف سازماني آن ريشه در مباني سوسياليستي داشت .
The Emergence of the Foundations of Socialism and Marxist Thought in Iran: An Analysis of Historical Documents 2 Abdolrahman Alem1* , Mohammad Ali Ahmadi 1 Professor, Faculty of Law & Political Science, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran 2 A PhD Candidate, Faculty of Law & Political Science, University of Tehran, Iran Received: 26 July 2021, Accepted: 30 January 2023 © University of Tehran Abstract In various sources, we have been reading that socialism and Marxism began their influence in Iran after the adoption of the Constitution along with the emergence of social democratic organizations and groups.
[in Persian] "Bayānat-e shobeh-ye pārlemāni-ye fergheh-ye democrat-e Irān (Statements of the Parliamentary Branch of the Democratic Party of Iran," (1911a, March 17) Roz’nāmeh-ye Irān-e no (Iranno Newspaper) 119, 2: 2.
[in Persian] “Az hayāt-e gharibān "(From the Life of Westerners,” (1910, November 9) Roz’nāmeh-ye Irān-e no (Iranno Newspaper) 2: 1-2.
Tehran: Tudeh Party of Iran Press.